Skip to content

“FOX GUARDING THE HENHOUSE” ON STATE TESTING REFORM

February 22, 2007

By Andrew Citizen

Columbia, S.C. – February 22, 2007 – The same company that currently reaps millions of dollars to grade South Carolina’s controversial Palmetto Achievement Challenge Test (PACT) has now been awarded a contract to oversee reforms to the test. Minnesota-based Data Recognition Corporation, which is represented in South Carolina by political heavyweight Warren Tompkins’ lobbying firm, Tompkins Kinard & Associates, won a $54 million contract in 2003 to grade the PACT.

Now, that same company has been awarded an $825,000 contract to recommend PACT reforms, an arrangement some consider a conflict of interest.

“Now that’s the fox guarding the henhouse,” said former State Board of Education member Terrye Seckinger.

Legislators agreed.

“I would be more interested in hearing a fresh perspective on PACT than hearing from someone who has been providing PACT services for years,” said State Rep. Phillip Shoopman, a former member of the State Board of Education. “I have yet to meet a teacher who is thrilled with PACT, so going back to that well doesn’t make sense to me.”

“Yes, they do have both of the contracts,” said Dr. JoAnne Anderson, Executive Director of the South Carolina Education Oversight Committee. “I understand there are some concerns but I have to respect the procurement process.”

Tompkins’ firm declined to comment.

PACT has come under intense criticism in the education community because it is not a “diagnostic” test, meaning it fails to provide teachers and parents with real-time results of children’s academic performance. It also fails to identify specific areas where children may need additional individual instruction.

As Spartanburg School District 3 Superintendent Dr. Jim Ray was recently quoted as saying, “PACT is useless as an instructional tool.”

PACT also fails to meet federal No Child Left Behind reporting standards and does not allow administrators to accurately compare our children’s academic progress with the progress of children in other states. Additionally, PACT is among the nation’s most expensive assessment tests, with its lengthy and error-prone grading process forcing South Carolina to spend as much as three or four times the per pupil testing amount spent by other states.

According to February 2007 report by the South Carolina Policy Council, “PACT has served as a cloak behind which major failures are hidden” because it “offers a distorted view of educational progress.” The report also states that PACT “has not provided the context for (state-to-state) comparison, nor can it prescribe the details needed to construct a plan for instructional reform.”

Newly-elected State Superintendent of Education Jim Rex has garnered positive newspaper headlines by saying that the option of eliminating PACT will remain “on the table.”

Those comments have provoked skepticism from the Education Oversight Committee.

“I think he’s trying to waffle,” Dr. Anderson said. “If you read his transition team report it doesn’t say ‘don’t (use) PACT.’ But then if the newspaper asks him he says that nothing is off the table. I think he’s just working real hard to try and include everybody right now.”

hpc-larger.jpg

Advertisements
5 Comments leave one →
  1. Douglas Howard permalink
    February 22, 2007 8:41 PM

    I have taught in SC,and have been a principal. I have had 40 years in the school system,and it is broken and way behind NC.

    I have tried to get this to the attention of the
    decision makers many times,but to no avail:

    I had the priviledge of teaching in NC for 4 years.
    Their EOG test (end of Grade). Is graded by computer on the day that the test is taken. (the computers are the property of each school so they don’t have to pay
    for the tests to be scored by outside $$$$$.
    The scores are available the next day.
    Passing the test is necessary for a student to be promoted .
    Those who do not pass the first time, are allowed to take the test again (they are remediated before the second try). Of course, the test covers the same skills,but is different in content,so the students don’t have the same questions again.
    Students who do not pass the test on the second try,must go to summer school or be retained.
    They must take the test again at the end of the summer school session. IF they don’t pass that time, they are retained.
    In SC everyone is promoted!! so, in reality, the test means nothing!!!!!!
    When are we going to fix this? IN my opinion, and so far that hasn’t been important, We are playing games,and not facing and fixing the problems in SC education. Why aren’t we ashamed yet of being near the bottom every year. SOMETHING IS WRONG.!!!!
    We need to fix the testing and promotion qualifications that do not now exist.
    When is someone going to fix the obvious flaws in our Education System?????

  2. February 23, 2007 5:21 AM

    Great story … and check out my blog for additional thoughts … http://earlcapps.blogspot.com

Trackbacks

  1. Fox Guarding Hen House « FITSNews For Now
  2. Fox Guarding Hen House (Two Words) « FITSNews For Now
  3. Response from Jim Foster to our PACT article « SCHotline

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: